Risk Retention Groups: A Basic Overview

Building blocks on a desk

November 17, 2026 |

Building blocks on a desk

In 1981, Congress passed legislation authorizing the formation of a new type of insurance company: the risk retention group (RRG). Just 5 years later, federal lawmakers expanded the types of liability insurance these policyholder-owned organizations could provide.

The legislation emerged from a period of significant challenges in the commercial insurance market. In the late 1970s, manufacturers faced rising product liability insurance premiums and concerns about the availability of coverage. By the mid-1980s, similar problems had spread to other types of liability insurance, prompting Congress to expand the original law.

Today, RRGs remain a distinct form of insurance organization, combining policyholder ownership with the ability to provide liability coverage across state lines under federal law.

What Is a Risk Retention Group?

An RRG is a liability insurance company owned by its policyholders, whose businesses or activities involve similar or related liability exposures. Rather than purchasing insurance exclusively from an independently owned commercial insurer, members obtain coverage through an insurance organization they collectively own.

The primary purpose of an RRG is to assume and spread the liability risks of its members. These members must be engaged in businesses or activities that are similar or related with respect to the liability exposures being insured.

Members pay premiums to the RRG, which assumes responsibility for covered claims under the terms of its insurance policies. Like other insurance companies, an RRG must maintain financial resources to meet its obligations and may purchase reinsurance to transfer portions of its insured risks.

One of the defining characteristics of an RRG is its ability to operate in multiple states without obtaining a separate insurance license in each state. This authority comes from the federal Liability Risk Retention Act of 1986 (LRRA), which establishes the legal framework governing RRGs.

Why Were Risk Retention Groups Created?

The origins of RRGs can be traced to the product liability insurance market of the late 1970s.

At the time, manufacturers faced substantial increases in product liability insurance premiums. Insurers expressed concerns about the frequency and cost of product liability lawsuits, while businesses faced difficulties obtaining affordable coverage.

A federal interagency task force examined conditions in the product liability insurance market, including the causes of rising premiums and concerns about insurance availability.

Congress responded in 1981 by passing the Product Liability Risk Retention Act. The legislation authorized businesses with similar product liability exposures to establish insurance companies that could provide product liability and completed operations coverage to their members across state lines.

The initial law was limited in scope. However, the liability insurance market experienced additional difficulties during the mid-1980s, when insurers increased premiums for a broader range of liability coverages.

In 1986, Congress expanded the law through the Liability Risk Retention Act. The amendments allowed RRGs to provide additional types of commercial liability insurance, subject to the statute's definition of liability and its restrictions.

The 1986 legislation also established the federal preemption provisions that continue to distinguish RRGs from other insurance companies.

How Do RRGs Differ from Other Captive Insurance Companies?

Although RRGs share characteristics with captive insurance companies, not all captives are RRGs, and not all RRGs are formed under captive insurance laws. Understanding the differences helps explain why RRGs occupy a distinct place in the insurance market.

First, ownership requirements differ. Other captive insurance companies may be owned by a single parent company, affiliated businesses, associations, or other qualifying entities. Under the LRRA, an RRG generally must be owned by the policyholders it insures. Federal law also permits an RRG to be owned by a qualifying organization whose members and owners satisfy the statute's requirements.

Another important distinction involves the types of insurance each can provide. Depending on their structure and domicile, other captive insurance companies may insure both first-party risks, such as property damage, and third-party risks, such as liability claims.

RRGs, by contrast, are limited to liability insurance and certain related reinsurance activities permitted under the LRRA. The law also permits RRGs to provide reinsurance for qualifying liability exposures of other RRGs, subject to statutory requirements.

RRGs cannot provide first-party property insurance, such as coverage for damage to a member's own buildings or equipment. The LRRA also excludes personal risk liability and an employer's liability with respect to its employees, except for legal liability under the Federal Employers' Liability Act. RRGs cannot provide workers compensation insurance.

Licensing requirements represent another significant difference.

Other captive insurance companies generally do not have the same federal authority to issue insurance policies directly across state lines. Depending on the coverage and arrangement, they may use a fronting insurer to issue policies in jurisdictions where the captive is not licensed.

An RRG, however, can provide qualifying liability insurance to members in multiple states after meeting the licensing requirements of its domicile and the applicable registration requirements of other states. It does not need a fronting insurer solely to satisfy separate insurance licensing requirements in those states.

There are also differences in regulation. Other captives are subject to the laws governing their particular structure and domicile. RRGs operate under a combination of state insurance laws and the federal LRRA, which limits the authority of states other than the domicile to regulate their operations.

How Are Risk Retention Groups Formed and Regulated?

Forming an RRG begins with selecting a domicile and meeting that jurisdiction's insurance licensing requirements.

Under federal law, newly formed RRGs must be chartered or licensed as liability insurance companies in a US state or the District of Columbia. The LRRA also contains a narrow grandfather provision for certain RRGs chartered in Bermuda or the Cayman Islands before January 1, 1985.

An RRG may be formed under a state's captive insurance laws or its traditional insurance laws, depending on the jurisdiction.

As part of the formation process, an RRG must submit a plan of operation or feasibility study to its domiciliary insurance commissioner before offering insurance. The plan must describe the proposed coverages, deductibles, coverage limits, rates, and rating classification systems.

The domiciliary regulator may also require additional information concerning the group's financial condition, business plan, management, underwriting practices, claims procedures, and reinsurance arrangements.

Once licensed, an RRG can operate in other states without obtaining separate insurance licenses. However, this does not mean that it is exempt from all regulation outside its domicile.

Before offering insurance in another state, the RRG must submit its plan of operation or feasibility study, including required revisions, to that state's insurance commissioner. It must also submit annual financial statements to the states where it conducts business. These statements must be certified by an independent public accountant and include the required opinion on loss and loss adjustment expense reserves.

States retain certain regulatory powers under the LRRA. For example, they may require RRGs to comply with unfair claims settlement practices laws, pay applicable premium taxes, and comply with laws addressing false, fraudulent, or deceptive practices.

Under specified circumstances, states may also conduct financial examinations or seek court orders involving RRGs that are financially impaired or in hazardous financial condition.

The result is a regulatory framework in which the domiciliary state has primary responsibility for overseeing an RRG, while other states retain specific powers established by federal law.

Advantages and Limitations of RRGs

The ability to operate across state lines is one of the principal features of the RRG structure.

An RRG licensed in its domiciliary state can provide qualifying liability insurance to members in other states without obtaining separate insurance licenses, provided it complies with the applicable requirements of the LRRA.

Policyholder ownership is another distinguishing feature. Rather than purchasing coverage exclusively from a commercial insurer owned by outside shareholders, RRG members collectively own the organization providing their insurance.

The structure also allows businesses and organizations with similar or related liability exposures to insure those risks through a shared insurance company.

However, RRGs have limitations that distinguish them from other insurance arrangements.

The liability-only restriction means that members requiring property insurance or other coverage outside the LRRA's scope must obtain that insurance elsewhere. For example, an RRG member needing coverage for damage to its own buildings or equipment would need a separate insurance arrangement.

RRGs also remain subject to the financial risks associated with operating an insurance company. They must maintain sufficient financial resources to meet claims and other obligations, and they can experience underwriting losses or financial difficulties.

Another important distinction concerns state insurance insolvency guaranty funds.

Unlike certain policyholders of state-licensed commercial insurers, RRG policyholders do not have access to state insurance insolvency guaranty fund protection for their RRG coverage. The LRRA requires RRG policies to include a notice informing policyholders of this limitation and explaining that the group may not be subject to all the insurance laws and regulations of their state.

These features make it important to understand both the federal operating authority granted to RRGs and the responsibilities associated with policyholder ownership.

RRGs and Federal Preemption

Although RRGs operate under state insurance laws, the LRRA provides federal protections that limit how other states can regulate them.

The law generally prevents states other than the RRG's domicile from imposing requirements that would make the group's operations unlawful or otherwise regulate its activities beyond the authority preserved by the statute.

These federal preemption provisions have been the subject of litigation.

One example is Alliance of Nonprofits for Insurance, Risk Retention Group v. Kipper, 712 F.3d 1316 (9th Cir. 2013).

In that case, the Alliance of Nonprofits for Insurance, Risk Retention Group, which was chartered in Vermont, challenged an order issued by Nevada's insurance commissioner. The order prohibited the RRG from issuing certain automobile liability insurance policies in Nevada because it did not hold a certificate of authority from the state.

The Ninth US Circuit Court of Appeals concluded that Nevada's restriction on the RRG's issuance of first-dollar automobile liability coverage was preempted by the LRRA.

The decision illustrates the importance of the LRRA's preemption provisions, which protect qualifying RRGs from certain state insurance requirements while preserving specified regulatory authority for individual states.

The Role of RRGs in Liability Risk Financing

RRGs have been part of the US liability insurance market since Congress first authorized them in 1981. The expansion of federal law in 1986 established a broader framework for businesses and organizations seeking to insure similar or related liability exposures through policyholder-owned insurance companies.

Although RRGs share characteristics with other captive insurers, their ownership requirements, liability-only coverage restrictions, and federal authority to operate across state lines distinguish them from other captive structures.

RRGs are not exempt from insurance regulation or the financial responsibilities associated with providing coverage. Rather, they operate within a specific federal and state regulatory framework designed for policyholder-owned liability insurance organizations.

Understanding that framework, along with the advantages and limitations of the RRG structure, provides a foundation for understanding the role of risk retention groups in captive insurance and liability risk financing.

November 17, 2026