Pinnacle Study Finds Continued Premium Growth Among Risk Retention Groups
November 17, 2026
Risk retention groups (RRGs) continued to experience premium growth in 2025, with medical professional liability accounting for the largest share of written premiums, according to Pinnacle Actuarial Resources' 2026 Risk Retention Group Benchmarking Study. The ninth annual study examines RRG financial performance, market share, underwriting results, and capitalization using publicly available financial statement data, primarily covering 2015 through 2025.
The report identified 218 RRGs with positive written premiums in 2025, reflecting a relatively stable number of operating groups over the past decade. According to Pinnacle, total RRG written premiums have grown steadily since 2011 and now approach $6 billion, despite fluctuations in the number of active groups.
Vermont remained the largest RRG domicile, with 69 groups reporting positive written premiums in 2025, followed by South Carolina with 39, Alabama with 25, and the District of Columbia with 23. According to the report, these four jurisdictions accounted for more than 70 percent of RRGs in the study. Alabama experienced notable growth over the preceding 5 years, increasing from 13 RRGs in 2021 to 25 in 2025.
Medical professional liability (MPL) remained the largest line of business for RRGs, generating approximately $3.18 billion in direct written premiums in 2025, compared with $2.96 billion in 2024. Other liability premiums increased from approximately $1.81 billion to $1.86 billion, while commercial auto liability premiums rose from $616 million to $826 million. Pinnacle reported continued premium growth across all three major lines.
The study also found that most RRGs concentrated their underwriting in a single line of business. Of the 218 groups reporting positive written premiums in 2025, 196 wrote more than 90 percent of their premiums in one line. According to Pinnacle, 94 specialized in medical professional liability, 51 in other liability, and 51 in commercial auto liability. The number specializing in commercial auto liability increased from 41 in 2021.
Medical Professional Liability Market Share Continues to Increase
RRGs accounted for approximately 0.5 percent of total direct written premiums across all insurance lines during the study period. However, their presence in medical professional liability was substantially greater. According to the report, RRG market share in this line increased from 17.5 percent in 2015 to 23.2 percent in 2025.
Premium growth in medical professional liability remained positive for both RRGs and the broader insurance industry over the past 7 years. Pinnacle found that unaffiliated medical professional liability RRGs experienced faster premium growth than groups affiliated with the MPL Association in three of the past 4 years.
Geographically, New York, Pennsylvania, California, Florida, and Texas represented the largest markets for RRG direct written premiums based on the location of insured risks. According to the report, New York had the largest premium volume, while Pennsylvania led among unaffiliated medical professional liability RRGs. Texas, California, and Florida were the largest markets for commercial auto liability RRG premiums.
Commercial auto liability also recorded substantial premium growth. Pinnacle found that RRG premiums in this line increased in all but one of the observed annual periods and outpaced the broader insurance industry in 4 of the past 5 years.
Underwriting Results and Capitalization
Despite continued premium growth, RRGs generally reported higher accident-year loss and loss adjustment expense ratios than the broader insurance industry over the 11-year study period. According to Pinnacle, combined loss and expense ratios for RRGs ranged from 80–91 percent, compared with 69–77 percent for the industry.
The report also identified differences within the medical professional liability market. RRGs affiliated with the Medical Professional Liability Association historically reported better loss ratios than unaffiliated groups, although their results have begun to deteriorate in recent years, according to Pinnacle.
Underwriting profitability remained a challenge for RRGs. Pinnacle found that RRGs reported underwriting losses in eight of the 11 years examined, while their accident-year combined ratios were at or above 100 percent throughout the study period. Calendar-year combined ratios averaged 103 percent over the past 8 years.
Net income showed considerable variation during the study period. According to Pinnacle, RRG net income declined substantially in 2022, when more than 47 percent of groups reported negative net income. Results improved in 2023, with the ratio of net income to surplus reaching 5.7 percent.
Capitalization remained a relative strength for RRGs compared with the broader insurance industry. According to the report, RRGs generally maintained lower ratios of net written premiums to surplus, indicating higher capitalization relative to premium volume. Medical professional liability RRGs affiliated with the MPL Association were also substantially better capitalized than their unaffiliated counterparts.
RRGs continued to retain a smaller proportion of their direct written premiums than the broader insurance industry. Pinnacle reported that RRGs retained approximately 56 percent of direct written premiums in recent years, compared with approximately 90 percent for the industry.
Underwriting Expenses Vary by Line of Business
Underwriting expenses differed considerably among the major RRG lines of business. According to Pinnacle, medical professional liability RRGs maintained expense ratios between 10 percent and 13 percent of direct written premiums over the 11-year period, while other liability RRGs generally reported ratios between 16 percent and 18 percent, declining to 15 percent in 2025.
Commercial auto liability RRGs experienced higher and more variable underwriting expenses, with ratios ranging from approximately 18–26 percent. Pinnacle also examined financial examination costs, finding average estimated fees of $31,863 among the RRGs included in its 2025 analysis, compared with $27,233 in its previous study.
The study found that RRGs continued to expand premium volume and maintain relatively strong capitalization, while experiencing higher loss ratios and more variable underwriting results than the broader insurance industry. According to Pinnacle, these financial trends differed significantly by line of business, particularly between medical professional liability, other liability, and commercial auto liability RRGs.
November 17, 2026