Runoff Insurers Evolve into Strategic Capital Partners

Runoff insurers have become key strategic players in the reinsurance market, offering tailored capital solutions and operational simplification to active insurers, according to a new AM Best report. Once viewed primarily as managers of discontinued or noncore books, these companies now play a central role in capital optimization strategies across the insurance sector.

The report highlights how the non-life runoff sector has matured, now dominated by a small group of technically sophisticated firms. These runoff specialists are recognized for their transactional agility and use of advanced analytics, which allows them to reprice risk, account for reserve development, and set liability caps. Dan Hofmeister, associate director at AM Best, said, "Today, these specialists are increasingly recognized for their technical sophistication, transactional agility, and ability to provide customized capital solutions."

Contrary to common perception, these firms do not simply assume distressed or high-risk portfolios. Instead, they apply disciplined underwriting and leverage accumulated claims data and refined reserving techniques to manage liabilities effectively. While these transactions can deliver capital relief and simplify operations for the ceding insurer, execution risks remain. These include regulatory hurdles, delays in legal entity transfers, and potential reputational concerns, particularly when policyholders view the transaction as an abdication of responsibility. "Cedents may also face reputational risk if policyholders or claimants perceive the transfer as a retreat from obligations, especially in high-profile or long-tail liability classes," Mr. Hofmeister said.

The report also raises concerns about counterparty risk. If a runoff acquirer becomes financially impaired or mishandles claims, insurers may face disputes, reputational harm, or lingering liability exposure.

As the market has evolved, so have the priorities of ceding insurers. While legal finality was once the main motivation for entering runoff deals, the focus has shifted toward capital efficiency. This shift allows runoff specialists greater flexibility in structuring transactions to meet insurers' regulatory and financial goals.

Copyright © 2026 by AM Best Rating Services, Inc. and/or its affiliates. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.