Captive.com logo

Captive Insurance News

Free Captive Wire Report

Tax Considerations for Captive Insurers

A FREE 16-page special report courtesy of Captive.com

Dig deep into important issues and trends in captive insurance. Download this FREE special report featuring practical knowledge and insights from nine respected captive insurance thought leaders!

Show Me My Free Report

Johnson & Johnson Successful on Appeal of New Jersey Tax Court Decision

Court Ruling Gavel
October 04, 2019

By Saren Goldner and P. Bruce Wright
Eversheds Sutherland (US) LLP

Johnson & Johnson (J&J) had paid New Jersey independent procurement tax on the full amount of premium paid (i.e., premium relating to both New Jersey risk and non–New Jersey risk) to its Vermont captive, Middlesex Assurance Company Limited, since enactment of the Nonadmitted and Reinsurance Reform Act (NRRA). This was based on J&J's determination that New Jersey was the home state on its policies. Prior to the enactment of the NRRA, J&J paid independent procurement tax only on the portion of the premium related to New Jersey risk, based on New Jersey legislation.

New Jersey, however, passed legislation adopting the NRRA, but, notwithstanding that the NRRA applies to both surplus lines tax and independent procurement tax, the New Jersey law only referred to the surplus lines tax.

The New Jersey Tax Court that first heard the case concluded that the legislature "intended" to include both independent procurement and surplus lines taxes, but the New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division disagreed, noting the New Jersey statute adopting the NRRA did not refer to the independent procurement tax and that there was no legislative history that supported the position to include independent procurement tax. 

As such, the court concluded that J&J was only subject to tax based on the law relating to independent procurements that was in effect prior to the New Jersey legislature's adoption of the NRRA, and, accordingly, found J&J liable only for independent procurement tax on New Jersey risk.

Saren Goldner and P. Bruce Wright are partners in the tax department of the law firm of Eversheds Sutherland (US) LLP. Ms. Goldner and Mr. Wright are located in New York.

Look out for the December edition of Captive Insurance Company Reports (CICR) for a more in-depth look at the Johnson & Johnson appeal.

Copyright © 2019, International Risk Management Institute, Inc.

Related Videos


Captive Insurance Company Reports
Follow Captive.com on Twitter

Twitter Feed